What is Character Evidence in Criminal Cases in Oklahoma?
In Oklahoma criminal trials, character evidence can play an important role. However, it’s important to understand the nature of character evidence, and the specific rules and limitations that govern its admissibility and use.
Character evidence refers to information or testimony presented in a legal context that pertains to a person’s character traits or disposition. It can include evidence about a person’s honesty, integrity, peacefulness, aggressiveness, trustworthiness, or other moral or behavioral attributes.
Types of Character Evidence
There are two main types of character evidence: reputation evidence and specific instances of conduct.
Reputation evidence involves presenting witnesses who can testify about the general reputation of a person in the community regarding specific character traits. For example, a witness might testify that a person is known in the community for being honest or dishonest, law-abiding or troublemaking, etc.
Evidence of specific instances of conduct involves introducing specific instances or examples of a person’s past behavior or conduct to demonstrate their character traits. However, the admissibility of specific instances of conduct as character evidence is often limited and subject to legal rules and restrictions.
Limitations of Character Evidence Use in an Oklahoma Criminal Trial
As with all evidence, character evidence must be relevant to an issue in a case. For example, in a trial for theft, evidence of the defendant’s reputation for honesty may be relevant. Character evidence may also be used for impeachment purposes, such as attacking the credibility of a witness.
Oklahoma Rules of Evidence Govern the Use of Character Evidence
Oklahoma, like other states, has rules of evidence that govern the admissibility of character evidence. These rules ensure that the evidence is reliable and not unfairly prejudicial.
In Oklahoma, character evidence is generally not admissible to prove conduct in criminal cases except:
- When offered to rebut other evidence of character presented by either the accused or the prosecution; or
- When a pertinent trait of the victim’s character is offered by an accused, or by the prosecution to rebut other proffered character witness evidence, or evidence of the victim’s peacefulness is offered by the prosecution in a homicide case to rebut evidence that the victim was the first aggressor; or for other exceptions under Oklahoma law.
Evidence of other crimes, wrongs, or acts is not admissible to prove the character of a person in order to show action in conformity with that character trait. It may, however, be admissible for other purposes, such as proof of motive, opportunity, intent, preparation, plan, knowledge, identity or absence of mistake or accident. (Okla. Stat. tit. 12 § 2404.)
So, a defendant may introduce evidence of their own character traits if they are relevant to the case, such as evidence of honesty in a theft case. Additionally, the prosecution may introduce evidence of the alleged victim’s character if it is relevant to the case, such as evidence of a victim’s violent tendencies in a self-defense case.
Methods of Introducing Character Evidence in an Oklahoma Criminal Trial
Where evidence of a person’s character or trait of character is admissible, proof may be offered via testimony as to reputation or by testimony in the form of opinion. This opinion testimony may be offered by an expert witness or by other witness testimony. It may also be offered on cross-examination to rebut assertions made by a witness or by the accused, or when relevant to specific instances of conduct.
Testimony may also be offered in cases in which a person’s character or a trait of character is an essential element of a charge, claim or defense, proof may be made of specific instances of his conduct. (Okla. Stat. tit. 12 § 2405.)
Courts often conduct a balancing test to determine whether the probative value of character evidence outweighs any potential prejudicial effect. This involves considering factors such as the relevance of the evidence, its reliability, and the risk of unfair prejudice.
Special Situations in Sexual Offense Cases
In Oklahoma, evidence of a victim’s sexual conduct is generally not admissible in a case involving an alleged sexual offense, subject to certain limited exceptions. This principle is in line with the rules governing the admissibility of character evidence and prior sexual behavior of the victim.
There are specific exceptions under Oklahoma law. Evidence of the victim’s sexual conduct may be admissible if it is offered for a purpose other than to prove the victim’s character or propensity. For example, such evidence may be relevant if it is offered to show motive, opportunity, intent, preparation, plan, knowledge, identity, absence of mistake, or lack of accident.
Before introducing evidence of the victim’s sexual conduct for any of the permissible purposes, the party seeking to introduce such evidence must provide advance notice to the court and the opposing party. This notice requirement is designed to ensure fairness and give the opposing party an opportunity to respond.
Even then, the court will typically conduct a balancing test to determine whether the probative value of the evidence outweighs any potential prejudice to the victim or unfair prejudice to the defendant.
Additionally, Oklahoma law imposes restrictions on the cross-examination of a victim regarding their prior sexual behavior. Such cross-examination is generally limited and subject to the court’s discretion to prevent harassment or undue invasion of privacy. (Okla. Stat. tit. 12 § 2412.)
It’s important to understand that the admissibility and use of character evidence are subject to specific legal rules and limitations, which may vary depending on the jurisdiction and the type of case. These rules are designed to ensure that character evidence is used appropriately and fairly in legal proceedings. Consult with a Muskogee criminal law attorney regarding the uses and applications of Oklahoma law to your case.
Ask a Muskogee Criminal Law Attorney
Contact the Muskogee lawyers at the Wirth Law Office – Muskogee to arrange a case evaluation a initial strategy sesssion today at (918) 913-0725. If you prefer to contact us by email, use the form at the top of this page.
